My favorite type of fishing spots are typically those that are high risk but with the chance for high reward. In fact, nowadays more often than not we’re pursuing these type of places; whether it’s spending time exploring new ones or returning to those that you just know that you haven’t seen its potential. So what happens when you make your first trip to a place like this and you end up leaving unsatisfied with how well you surveyed the opportunity and the “reward” is still uncertain? Do you give it another go or scratch it off the list? Afterall, there are too too many places to fish and too little time. Well, I find myself in this very predicament with an extremely unique lake. It will all make more sense after I describe the “risk” and the “reward” in a little more detail. I’m gonna need your help! What would you do? A year or two ago, Phil mentioned happening across a lake high in the Uinta backcountry while scouting for elk. As he and his buddy stepped closer to the small lake, Phil naturally began to survey its waters. Light was getting low but as he peered into the small lake he saw what appeared to be a 25″+ trout cruising near the surface. The image was seared into his memory and stored for a later date. A fish like that in a high mountain lake is a very uncommon sight – especially in Utah. This last summer I found myself alone and in search of a place to get lost for a day or two. It was the perfect opportunity to head somewhere new. I looked through notes for those places I’d yet to explore. It was then that the memory of a past conversation came to mind. I called up Phil and got more details on this potential hidden gem. I was reminded – just as I was told the first time he told me about this lake, it’s a pain in the junk to find/hike into. However, Phil also told me more about this lake that made it simply impossible to pass up. After first discovering the lake, he had looked through the DWR’s records on this body of water and found that it was unnamed and hadn’t been stocked in the past 30+ years. Hmmmm….ok, sign me up?! A high alpine lake with a naturally sustaining population of fish with specimen over two foot? No brainer – regardless of how hard it was to access. My dog, Boogie, and I pulled to a stop after a long bumpy drive. As I exited into the darkness of night, the sound of running water and crickets was joined by the type of hiss that makes your heart drop. A leaky back tire. Sweet. It was late so I re-parked to a spot that would make it a bit easier in the morning to switch out my spare and hit the hay. I woke from my slumber to a beautiful morning. It wasn’t long before we were on the trail. We made our way further into the broad valley. Around noon and after a few hours of hiking, I arrived at the beginning of the real ascent. I had fishing gear packed, multiple days of food, and a tent since rain was in the forecast so my pack was over a third my body weight. It was about to get gnarly. The next leg included no trail and over 1000 vertical feet of gain in less than a mile with no trail. Boogie looked ready so we charged it. Basically… the next hour was super rad. Oh ya, I usually hike in Chacos too. We found our destination at the base of a rocky hillside that was still partially covered with snow. It was dead silent. I dropped my pack and Boogie and I rehydrated and took in the surroundings. I couldn’t help but notice some extremely light-colored shapes making their way along a very pronounced drop-off. I also couldn’t help but engage so I immediately grabbed my all-time favorite rod (the LOOP Cross S1 386-4) and rigged up. After a few misses I hooked my first zombie cuttie. The fish were collectively the most peculiar specimens I’d seen. They all seemed healthy (all 15-18″) and overall were great size for high alpine fish but they were all very pale and appeared kind of sickly. It’s hard to describe so I’ll let the pictures do the talking. The contrast agains the red rocks was striking. I caught a few of the zombies before they headed for deeper water. After the fish left for deeper waters, I took the opportunity to reflect on life for awhile. Life is busy and my mind often moves around very quickly so it’s often somewhat of a challenge to really get the opportunity to spend time thinking free from distraction. I did this for an hour or two. Boogie didn’t seem to mind as he lay sleeping in the sun. What happened next was really odd. After coming back from my thoughts to ‘the present’ I felt strongly that for whatever reason, I needed to leave the lake. This wasn’t a very appealing thought considering I’d only arrived a few hours before, I don’t like to ignore feelings like that so I made the decision to do just that. Before I packed up, I climbed up the rocky hillside a little higher to look out over the lake. It was only then that I thought of something…if these fish had been in here and naturally reproducing without a total winterkill anytime in the last 30+ years then this lake has to be pretty deep. It’s a tiny lake. It’s 150yds long and about 65 yards accross. I wish the water wasn’t so milky that day so I could have gotten a better idea of the topography of the lake. As a result, I have a grip of questions circling in my head: how deep is it, why do the fish look so weird – is it dietary? What are they eating? Are there a good number of sizable fish in there? Does anyone else fish this lake? All these questions lead me back to another question – DO I GO BACK? Is it worth taking the time to go back versus going somewhere else? Is it worth the hike? Is it possible to effectively fish it without staying the night? Are those crazy-looking fish worth it – even if there are some thugs in there? Do cucumbers taste better pickled? What do you think? What would you do? To return or not to return – that is the question. As not to leave you hanging, we ended up hiking down to the valley and setup camp there. Needless to say, hike down was much more pleasant than the hike up. We fished for small brookies and whitefish until an evening storm rolled in. I took refuge in my tent and Boogie tried to guilt trip me into letting him join me in the tent. Instead he took refuge from the downpour in the vestibule. After the rain subsided we enjoyed a quiet evening in a beautiful valley. Ultimately it was an awesome trip to the mountains. So now I need you to help me decide. What would you do and why? breatherview-of-the-valleytuckeredhome-sweet-homeriverside-camphe-wants-inbrookie-on-the-dropperwhitefish-macrome-and-the-pup 21 Responses JB April 22, 2014 Go back. Go. Back. Reply Patrick April 22, 2014 All very good questions…. I am sure it will haunt you until you go back. Reply Dallas April 22, 2014 My curiosity would drive me to return, unless you got the same “feeling” about returning. Plus, its not just the fishing, but the overall outdoor experience that you get from going again. Reply Nathan Leavitt April 22, 2014 I think it will drive me to go back too. Who knows when though. I think my feelings were isolated to that specific day/circumstance for whatever reason. I totally agree it’s not all about the fishing but when there’s so many places that you can experience the same level of adventure and beauty, it’s hard to decide sometimes and the fishing is often the deciding variable! Reply Parker April 22, 2014 Email me the name of the lake and I’ll check it out for you. I have a few Uinta gems myself, but I have to admit I’ve never seen anything like the eyes on those cutts. Or the milky water. Reply Nathan Leavitt April 22, 2014 The lake has no name. It’s definitely a unique lake! Reply Parker April 23, 2014 Hey- coordinates are ok by me too. 😉 Awesome report. Love the blog. Ralf Czerny April 23, 2014 You should definitely go back. At least once! I have found similar places like this in the Uintahs but also in Idaho, Montana, Nevada and Wyoming. If you go only once, too many questions remain unanswered. If you go again, some of those questions are answered and some questions are rendered irrelevant. Be sure to wash your hands and feet in the water. Touch the stones (as stupid as that sounds) and “feel” the spirit of the water and stones. And as you leave, talk to the trees and ask them to watch over the spot. I know that sounds all “tree-huggy” but becoming part of a spot makes it something you take with you and you never lose it. I cant hike to those places any longer, I’m to old and can’t walk that far but those places are in my heart forever. Once you have been there twice, whether you go again or not doesn’t really matter. Reply Nathan Leavitt April 23, 2014 Thanks for the comment, Ralf. Very well put. That doesn’t sound stupid at all. I love the visuals that created. As often as I try to make sure that I soak in my surroundings I love the idea of specific actions tying me to my surroundings. I’ll often gather a few rocks to bring home from special waters for time sakes. I say it half tongue and cheek but if you need anyone carry on the legacy of those spots and provide you pics and stuff let us know! In all seriousness though, thanks for stopping by and don’t be a stranger, Ralf! Reply Dan April 23, 2014 What drainage is this in is it on the north or south slope? Reply lisa April 23, 2014 Completely intrigued. Those fish are something special. This might be a text book example of Allopatric speciation? I think you need to go back and hit it again hard. Would make for another interesting blog post and I think it would help rest your sole. Maybe bring me back some DNA samples while your there. Reply Nathan Leavitt April 29, 2014 I think I will try to get back. This time I’ll go back with Phil so he can nerd out! I think you’re spot on with the allopatric speciation. Phil could probably speak more to it. Reply Phil April 29, 2014 Good work Lisa getting all scientific and geeky! Love it! I would agree regarding the speciation. Super weird fish and definitely isolated/ bottlenecked. I have never seen such a pale fish. Really weird… Coloration almost like a sickly rainbow, but spotting like a colorado cutt. The historical monitoring data suggests, “Cutthroat exhibiting rainbow characteristics.” Super weird… I think we will plan on returning at some point. I like the idea of taking some fin clips/genetic samples Lisa. That would tell us the a lot about what is really going on here. Thanks for the comment! Reply Lisa April 29, 2014 Phil, thanks for the feedback. I wanted to hear your thoughts on the matter as well. If you guys need a lab assistant on your journey out there I would love to join and observe. I’m a hardcore backpacker and I think the campfire conversations about Zombie Lake would be interesting. I’d even carry the heaviest pack. Haha! Either way, I am interested in hearing more about this eerie place. Will April 29, 2014 Creepy and amazing. I loved hiking way off the beaten path back when I was growing up. I got away from that in the years gone by…huge regret in my life. Currently my wife and I are on a quest to get fit so we can enjoy these excursions together. This site and the stories told are a huge inspiration. If you care to pass along one or two of your less secret, easier spots, I would appreciate that very much. Just looking to get away from the combat zone of the Provo as I am farily new to the area. Thanks again for sharing your experiences on this site. Reply Nathan Leavitt April 29, 2014 Will, thanks for stopping by. I’m pumped to hear you and your wife have this plan together. That’s awesome! I’m glad we could be small part in your motivation! Good luck. Email sent! Reply Krammit April 30, 2014 2 things I really like… Fishing, and Zombies… Sounds like a no brainer to me. Also keep in mind you may need a photographer “wink” 🙂 Reply Matt April 30, 2014 I’ve had a feeling that I need to start doing some exploring in the Uintahs. Great story…thanks for sharing! I enjoy reading your adventures…keep ’em coming! Reply Tobin May 3, 2014 What should you do? Let Boogie in the tent for god sakes!! Reply Chris May 3, 2014 Nathan, I loved reading this and seeing the photos! As far as whether or not you should go back thats tricky. Perhaps the fact that you went in the first place will help, you went beacuse you had unanswered questions; you were curious and you went for the thrill. It seems as though you have more questions now than you did when you started. I dont think you satisfied your original drive and im thinking if you dont go back it will always be a memory you wished you had. Keep up the good work! Reply Brett June 20, 2014 Nate, Consider going back later in the year. Anytime other than when you were there. I’m no Ichthyologist but maybe it had something to do with the temperature and possibly recently making their way up from deeper water. Leaving for Southern Utah this Sunday for a week. Reply Leave a Reply to Patrick Cancel Reply Your email address will not be published.CommentName* Email* Website Sign me up for the newsletter!